“trained as an architect”

No photos in the post, just a bit of a rant.

Recently my wife and I had another couple over to our house for dinner.  Like us, they were both architects, but, like my wife, who now practices as a land use attorney, neither of them was currently working in an architecture/design office.  This is frighteningly common.  Maybe other professions have an equal or greater attrition rate, but certainly architecture suffers greatly from a brain drain of talent and ability.

In poll after poll, architects testify to being one of the most unhappy of all professions, with very high rates of divorce, alcoholism and suicide. And, compared to other professionals with equal years of post-secondary school education, they are most consistently underpaid.  My carpenter friends may laugh at this, but none of them are willing to trade paychecks if that includes the monthly student loan payments.

Maybe the fact the vast majority of tasks that go in to making a building have precious little to do with design contributes to the disillusionment experienced by architects.  We can say that all of the associated tasks contribute to the “design”, but I doubt any of us went to architecture school and sweated through the countless hours of studios and humiliations of jury reviews because municipal code review or zoning analysis was just so exciting.

A tough economy makes this brain drain even worse.  So many architects, young and old, are not working in the field, not of their choice. Architecture unemployment is around 20% nationwide.  Underemployment, at least anecdotally, is 100%.  There are no clear statistics that I know of for this attrition, but for 2006, there were 7500 students graduating from accredited architecture schools, but only about 3000 gaining licenses.  More than half either never become registered or drop out.  Many others, like my wife, become licensed but no longer work as architects.

Do architecture schools fail to spell out the truth of the profession to prospective and current students?  Considering that less than 25% of architecture school faculty are licensed architects, you can hardly blame them for not knowing.  (That this low rate of licensed architects teaching architecture exists is another problematic topic)  Does popular media and myth over-hype the perceived romance of being an architect?  Probably so.

I love what I do, even if so much of my time is spent on technical and bureaucratic tasks.  That so many of my colleagues are leaving the profession, or never fully entered it, is profoundly depressing.  The extremely poor quality, both technical and aesthetic, of the built environment, the ugliness of our cities, the wastefulness of our construction industries, is directly related to the deplorable depletion of the ranks of rigorously trained, hard-working architects.  In the United States, the vast majority of buildings are put together by developers.  It is no coincidence that in a landscape where aesthetics are considered so much window-dressing, and a public would rather save a few bucks than have buildings to be proud of, architects find few handholds.

If anyone knows of any reliable statistics on the number of people “trained as architects” that are no longer working in the profession, I would love to see them.  That the AIA, NCARB and schools of architecture have no idea what this number is, well…

Advertisements

4 thoughts on ““trained as an architect”

  1. For those of us fortunate enough to have a job, the slowdown has allowed us to spend more focusing and reflecting on projects either under construction or recently completed. For the dozen of projects under construction, architects along with architectural interns have been able to gain valuable experience reviewing shop drawings, participating in the construction administration phase, and following through on the project instead of jumping to the next one. While we look for new work, our firm is encouraging everyone to take time to learn new computer programs, increase our knowledge on the subject of sustainability (take the LEED exam), give lunch presentations on various subjects, and spend time reaching out to existing clients. However, for those who graduated in the past year or two, the recession has been a nightmare. Since the downturn began, our firm has not hired any graduates from architecture schools. It is my hope that as the economy rebounds we are able to hire and inspire recent graduates and give them the opportunity that our generation had.

  2. I am thinking of leaving as well, not by choice but by necessity. Technically, I suppose, I’ve already been forced out. I’ll make a great census taker, though.

  3. I am most certainly caught up in whatever crazy and dynamic crisis this profession is going through. I am a recent graduate from an accredited architecture program, have 3 years residential experience, but nothing closely resembling work in the field. Nobody I graduated with can say they are happy with where they are professionally. Given this, I would have to agree that it is rather depressing to look at all the ugliness that surrounds us in the urban environment, knowing I could do better but am forced to stand back and feel helpless and unable to pay my bills with the thousands of dollars and hours spent on an education. At the time, it was easy to think I would make a difference with studio projects fueled by passionate and brilliant ideas. However, this all only exists in theory and cannot seem to rationalize itself in the real world because of a broken system that we had nothing to do with, are told to change, but cannot touch. Keeping hope is important, one day it will all flow out at the right time and we will make a big enough difference to change the world.

    1. I really hope things pick up for you. As I mentioned, when I graduated things were pretty sad, but nothing like this. Our profession goes through the death-throes every 8-10 years, but this one has been particularly ugly. I really do mourn the talent that has left the field.
      For what it’s worth, my work here has picked up dramatically and the next 6 months is looking good.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s