my lucky-orange-shirt obsession

I have a bit of a superstitious disposition.  I try to wear my lucky hat when fishing.  It frankly does matter which pencil I draw with.  And for every presentation of a new design or interview with potential clients, I wear an orange shirt.

Not the same shirt mind you.  Almost any orange shirt will do, and over the 16-plus years of this predilection, I have had quite a few.  However, it all started quite innocently and probably took a year or two off my life in the period of  few minutes.

When I was in grad school, my first architecture jury was approached with even more than the usual amount of apprehension.  I was about to present my work in front of some of the most respected, most famous, architects and educators on the East Coast.  I had done well at the local state university and worked in the architecture world for a few years but now I felt I was about to be handed my ass and kicked out the door of the fancy ivy league institution.  Clearly a Kentucky kid was about to be whupped.

I was working on a painfully complex project with carefully interlocking spaces and building elements.  To demonstrate this I had a series of color-coded plans and building sections.  Red for circulation, blue for public spaces, etc.  And, not by design, the day of the jury I sported an orange shirt.

not the jury in question, just some flavor of the moment

In my undergrad school, juries were often savage affairs of public humiliation and even occasionally criticism.  I assumed this fancy grad school would turn that up a notch or two, and as this was my first grad school jury, I was expecting the worse.  So, when a preceding student presented two or three sketchy drawings and received a flurry of sympathetic response, this did not ease my anxious heart, it only deepened the truly unknown depth of the chasm I was about to be hurled into.

My turn.  The pin-up wall behind me was chock full of my drawings, models, sketches, diagrams, etc.  I had worked my ass off and hoped to get some quality criticism and to frankly make it to the other side of this.  As my friends know, public speaking is a bit of a disaster for me.  I blush, get flustered, stumble over my own words, etc.  So, as I begin my description of my project, I am stunned, completely flummoxed when one of the jurors stands up and very loudly and aggressively says,  “what’s with all these colored drawings, all this is distracting, it’s all just so much eye-candy!”  “And, what’s with this orange shirt, are you trying to distract us?!”

Umm… ugh…excuse me?

He launched into this yet again, declaiming my project and my shirt.  And again.  And again.  Mind you this is with me only ONE SENTENCE into my description.  He didn’t even have the decency to let me finish before he attacked me.  Blushing and bit confused (“I don’t really remember this happening at UK”), I asked him if he was done.  That prompted new vigor and even more complex and fierce denunciations.  So I asked again.  And maybe this time I was a bit aggressive in turn.  And maybe I told him he could just sit down and that I deserved the opportunity to finish my description and get some comments from the other jurors.  And maybe I suggested that he could sit the fuck down and I possibly helped him to do just that.  With my hands on his shoulders (being smaller than me certainly increased my bravery), he sat, and in the awkward, stunned silence of the assembled crowd I started, again, my description.   Much to my surprise, I got through the whole thing with my prof speaking quietly into the ear of the asshole juror the whole time.  I don’t know what he said, but Mr. Asshole didn’t utter another word as his fellow jurors gave me some tough but really valid and needed critique.  Jury over and, only a few months into my grad school experience, a bit of a reputation forged.  One that I didn’t want, didn’t seek, didn’t need.  Having even more people show up for my juries to see if I would manhandle another juror was not good for a reluctant public speaker.

In any case, I survived grad school and in memory of that juror, whom I later found out was dean of another ivy league grad school, Dean Asshole, I have worn an orange shirt to ensure success in all of my presentations over the last 16 years or so.  And it works almost every time.  Needless to say, the thought of finding myself without a clean orange shirt on the day of a presentation is a bit of nightmare.  So we can’t let that happen.

3 thoughts on “my lucky-orange-shirt obsession

  1. Good for you! I have found that those who are most critical are either less talented, less secure, threatened by competence, or all of the above.

    It took me a really long time to realize (& I sometimes still forget!) that the loud protest or instant knee-jerk “No” is a reflection of whatever’s going on within its source. 🙂

  2. I never quite remembered it like that.

    All I can ever recall with certainty was the lack of rigour, inconsistency of criticism in regard to the brief and the general disagreement between the various critics. There was, however, an extremely healthy and openly vibrant discussion within studio of what is architecture to us. That was far more important than the end of semester reviews.

    All in all Mark, if it wasn’t for our late night discussions I would have quit grad school way before we graduated.

    1. Andrew Tyley I presume. Nice to hear from you and I concur, if it wasn’t what I learned from you and few others I wouldn’t have learned anything there.
      Hope you are well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s